Working template

Recovery exercise scorecard

A companion to What a recovery test should actually prove.

Download the text file to fill it in with your own details, or print a blank copy.

Agree on objectives with the business owner before the exercise. Record every time with a timezone and state when the recovery clock begins.

Plan

Service / business owner:  

Exercise lead / participants and roles:  

Exercise type: tabletop discussion / walkthrough of the written procedure / functional restore into an isolated environment / full failover of the live service

Recovery time objective:   Recovery point objective:  

Where the objectives came from and when the business owner last confirmed them:  

Scenario / authorized environment:  

Backup or replica used, its location, and its age at the start:  

Dependencies required for the service to be usable (identity, network, DNS, licenses, encryption keys, integrations):  

Representative transaction:  

Abort criteria and rollback if the exercise itself causes harm:  

Milestones

Milestone Timestamp Evidence / limitation
Interruption begins
Interruption detected
Recovery authorized
Restore starts
Data available
Dependencies available
Business transaction accepted
Users informed that service is usable

Checks

Check Expected Observed Pass / fail / untested
Restored data age
Integrity / representative contents
Identity and permissions
Encryption keys and secrets available without the primary environment
Restore source was a copy isolated from the primary environment (offline, immutable, or separate account)
Written procedure and contact list were reachable without the primary environment
Business transaction
Integrations and scheduled jobs
Time objective
Point objective

Manual interventions / missing instructions:  

Steps that depended on one specific person:  

Unmet objective, owner, and retest:  

Close-out

  • [ ] Test copies are retired or retained under the approved plan.
  • [ ] Temporary access is removed.
  • [ ] Normal protection and monitoring are confirmed.
  • [ ] Procedure updated with what was learned; version and date recorded.
  • [ ] Results shared with the business owner and, where relevant, the people who ask for them in due diligence.
Finding Improvement Owner Due date / retest

Common failure modes

  • The backup restores but nobody can sign in because identity was not part of the scenario.
  • Objectives were set by the technical team and never confirmed by the business owner.
  • The exercise is announced, rehearsed, and run by the one person who built the system.
  • A pass is recorded for a tabletop as if it were a functional restore.

Bounded conclusion and acceptance (state the exercise type in the conclusion):  

Next exercise date / trigger (vendor change, major upgrade, new dependency, staffing change):  

This scorecard covers one service and one scenario. It does not establish firm-wide continuity; repeat it per Tier 1 service and vary the scenario.